Talk:Categories: Difference between revisions

removing old stuff (old as in 1 hour or so), some replies. a point taken.
noting link to this page issue, which is better for portability than categories, and the exceptions (trollist and mediawiki terms) to the "stick to the dictionary" rule
Line 4: Line 4:


:::even, better, I deleted it as an unused redirect. Why you always gotta be so anti-[[MediaWiki]]?
:::even, better, I deleted it as an unused redirect. Why you always gotta be so anti-[[MediaWiki]]?
:::It's easier to tolerate mediawiki when it does not invent stupid names that are not in the dictionary.  IT is also easier to tolerate [[Lowest Troll]]s who do not do that much.


::The [[main namespace]] must parallel the [[Special:namespace]] for such words, else you get into horrors almost immediately.  You can't fight your underlying softwaere.
::The [[main namespace]] must parallel the [[Special:namespace]] for such words, else you get into horrors almost immediately.  You can't fight your underlying softwaere.


:::That's a valid point; I'll take notice
:::That's a valid point; I'll take notice
::::It is an exception to the rule about not using words that aren't in the dictionary;  So also is [[trollist]] terminology that has evolved to describe struggles for power in [[large public wiki]]s, and for which there is as yet no clear terminology except maybe Marxist rhetoric... which we should avoid.


-------
-------
Line 62: Line 66:


:A critical category.
:A critical category.
------------------
''According to [[talk:link to this page]]'',
It is possible to use [[categories]] like:
*defines or challenges the mission of [[Consumerium:itself]]
*helps [[Consumerium itself]] [[develop:itself]]
*helps [[Consumerium itself]] [[research:itself]]
*helps [[Consumerium itself]] [[publish:itself]]
But adding such categories is actually messy, and it means paages will be very often in multiple categories.  Tags work better than categories for a great many things includingt this I think.
Also if you shift off [[mediawiki]] your [[categories]] won't necessarily stick, while the links will.  For instance to use [[tiddlywiki]] for [[Publish:namespace]] is fine if you did it with links, but not if you did it with categories.
Return to "Categories" page.