Voting: Difference between revisions

    From Consumerium development wiki R&D Wiki
    (re-ordering, mentioning advantages)
    (rescued and adapted from en.consumeria.info)
    Line 10: Line 10:


    ''This is one of many [[open questions]] that need to be resolved.''
    ''This is one of many [[open questions]] that need to be resolved.''
    ==Planned vote structure==
    *[[User:Username/My representational vote]] (i.e. proxy or [[Indirect Vote]], this is probably not used at all in the end)
    *[[User:Username/Boycotts]]
    *[[User:Username/Avoids]]
    *[[User:Username/Supports]]
    *[[User:Username/Recommends]]
    *[[User:Username/Hedges]]
    *[[User:Username/Hedges heavily]]
    Use following syntax (vote only once on each "thing")
    *[[Company X]]
    *[[Country X]]
    *[[Product group X]]
    *...
    One can add any number of reasons by prefixing like this (you can intermix commas with "and"s so don't worry about that.
    '''[[Company X]] for [[Reason 1]], [[Reason 2]] and [[Reason 3]]'''
    in the above articles to cast your votes. Vote only once on one thing
    ==What things can you vote on?==
    Everyone with over 50 edits may vote on any thing (it should be somehow related to production, trading or shoping),  or  but only the following will be tallied [[:Category:Companies|Companies]], [[:Category:Brands|Brands]], [[:Category:Products|Products]], [[:Category:Product groups|Product groups]], [[Category:Countries]] and [[:Cateogry:Areas|Areas]]. If Votes overlap or conflict, the first or last vote encountered will be counted. This is yet to be decided.
    ==What's this I keep hearing about a dual voting system?==
    [[Indirect Votes]] probably won't be implemented due to lack of interest
    ===What one can vote?===
    Direct votes are:
    <table bgcolor="Black">
    <tr><td bgcolor="Black"><font color=#009900>'''+2'''</font></td><td> Recommends [[Company X]] </td></tr>
    <tr><td bgcolor="Black"><font color=#009900>'''+1'''</font></td><td> Supports [[Company X]] </td></tr>
    <tr><td bgcolor="Black"><font color=#009900>'''+1'''</font></td><td>Tries to support [[Company X]] </td></tr>
    <tr><td bgcolor="Black"><font color=yellow>'''0'''</font></td><td>is neutral about or</td>
    <td bgcolor="Black"><font color=yellow>'''00 (+1 and -1)'''</font></td><td>Hedges [must find better word] or</td>
    <td bgcolor="Black"><font color=yellow>'''0000 (+2 and -2)'''</font></td><td>Hedges heavily</td></tr>
    <tr><td bgcolor="Black"><font color=#CC0000>'''-1'''</font></td><td>Tries to avoid [[Company X]] </td></tr>
    <tr><td bgcolor="Black"><font color=#CC0000>'''-1 '''</font></td><td>Avoids [[Company X]]</td></tr>
    <tr><td bgcolor="Black"><font color=#CC0000>'''-2 '''</font></td><td>Boycotts [[Company X]] </td></tr>
    </table>
    <table><tr><td>'''All 0's move the result towards'''</td><td bgcolor="Black"><font color="yellow">50% positive.</font></td></tr></table>
    ----
    ==Voting result for Company X==
    '''Vote average on -2≤x≤2 scale normalized to 100%:'''
    <table width=100% cellpadding=15>
      <tr>
          <td bgcolor="Gray" width=100% align=center><font color="Black">'''Result Scale 1'''</font></td>
      </tr>
    </table>
    <table bgcolor="Black" cellpadding=15 width="100%">
      <tr bgcolor=Black>
        <td bgcolor=Black width=40%><font color=#CC0000>0 ≤ x <40% positive on Company X (Red)</font> </td>
        <td bgcolor=Black width=20%><font color=Yellow>40 ≤ x ≤ 60% (Yellow)</font></td>
        <td bgcolor=Black width=40%><font color=#009900>60 < x ≤ 100%</font></td>
      </tr>
    </table>
    ==What's the ratio of 0's compared to all votes (percentage)==
    Other possible words to refer to this metric. These include:
    *Levering towards 50% positive (bad. reference to leverage)
    *Middlage/Middling (middlage is propably better, pronounced french way)
    *Quasi-disputedness (maybe, maybe not)
    *Neutralifying (maybe, maybe not)
    *It's trollage again! All your 2 cows immediemente!
    This metric is an '''Average''' ('''scale may have to be adjusted later''' when we can get info on what levels voting 0's settle into)
    <table cellpadding=15><tr><td bgcolor="Black"><font color=#FF6600>'''60  ≤ x ≤ 100%''' of votes are 0's</font></td><td color=#FF6600>Notice the range here is 40% wide</td></tr>
    <tr><td bgcolor="Black" width=100%><font color=#CC0000>'''45 ≤ x < 60%''' of votes are 0's</font></td></tr>
    <tr><td bgcolor="Black"><font color=#6600CC>'''30 ≤ x < 45%''' of votes are 0's</font></td></tr>
    <tr><td bgcolor="Black"><font color=#000099>'''15 ≤ x < 30%''' of votes are 0's</font></td></tr>
    <tr><td bgcolor="Black"><font color=#009900>'''0 ≤ x < 15%''' of votes are 0's</font></td></tr></table>
    ----
    =Voting in the future=
    In the future you can use one line to vote on multiple entities on one line.
    *[[User:Username/Prefers]]
    *[[User:Username/Prefers strongly]]
    All votables that are before the keyword '''over''' gets voted up and every votable after that gets voted down.
    *<font color="Green">Prefers [[X]]</font><font color="Red"> over [[Y]] </font>results in  +1 and -1 respectively
    *<font color="Green">Strongly prefers [[X]] and [[Y]] </font><font color="Red">  over Z </font> results in  +2, +2 and -2 respectively
    * <font color=green>Strongly prefers [[Product X]] and [[Product Y]]<font color=red> over [[Product Z]]</font> <for [[reason 1]]>
    etc.etc.
    [[Category:Help]]

    Revision as of 18:09, 20 October 2010

    Voting refers to any system of making multiple choice collectively - it is typically used in elections to form a government which must make binding decisions that affect everyone, or elect a board (or sometimes even the management) of an enterprise, or choose various measures that affect company operations. See w:voting systems for some more depth on this.

    See edits, votes and bets for the debate about how to decide the final Consumerium buying signal.

    Some basic paradigms have been suggested to measure the support of campaigns:

    • Direct Vote requires many votes and rewards heavy participation, and,
    • Indirect Vote requires fewer votes and rewards faction organization
    • and the oddly-named WikiVote which seems to overlap with both of them

    This is one of many open questions that need to be resolved.

    Planned vote structure

    Use following syntax (vote only once on each "thing")

    One can add any number of reasons by prefixing like this (you can intermix commas with "and"s so don't worry about that.

    Company X for Reason 1, Reason 2 and Reason 3

    in the above articles to cast your votes. Vote only once on one thing

    What things can you vote on?

    Everyone with over 50 edits may vote on any thing (it should be somehow related to production, trading or shoping), or but only the following will be tallied Companies, Brands, Products, Product groups, and Areas. If Votes overlap or conflict, the first or last vote encountered will be counted. This is yet to be decided.

    What's this I keep hearing about a dual voting system?

    Indirect Votes probably won't be implemented due to lack of interest

    What one can vote?

    Direct votes are:

    +2 Recommends Company X
    +1 Supports Company X
    +1Tries to support Company X
    0is neutral about or 00 (+1 and -1)Hedges [must find better word] or 0000 (+2 and -2)Hedges heavily
    -1Tries to avoid Company X
    -1 Avoids Company X
    -2 Boycotts Company X


    All 0's move the result towards50% positive.

    Voting result for Company X

    Vote average on -2≤x≤2 scale normalized to 100%:

    Result Scale 1
    0 ≤ x <40% positive on Company X (Red) 40 ≤ x ≤ 60% (Yellow) 60 < x ≤ 100%

    What's the ratio of 0's compared to all votes (percentage)

    Other possible words to refer to this metric. These include:

    • Levering towards 50% positive (bad. reference to leverage)
    • Middlage/Middling (middlage is propably better, pronounced french way)
    • Quasi-disputedness (maybe, maybe not)
    • Neutralifying (maybe, maybe not)
    • It's trollage again! All your 2 cows immediemente!

    This metric is an Average (scale may have to be adjusted later when we can get info on what levels voting 0's settle into)

    60 ≤ x ≤ 100% of votes are 0'sNotice the range here is 40% wide
    45 ≤ x < 60% of votes are 0's
    30 ≤ x < 45% of votes are 0's
    15 ≤ x < 30% of votes are 0's
    0 ≤ x < 15% of votes are 0's

    Voting in the future

    In the future you can use one line to vote on multiple entities on one line.

    All votables that are before the keyword over gets voted up and every votable after that gets voted down.

    • Prefers X over Y results in +1 and -1 respectively
    • Strongly prefers X and Y over Z results in +2, +2 and -2 respectively

    etc.etc.