User:Jukeboksi/Blog/June2004: Difference between revisions
no edit summary
(argumentation for Opinion Wiki) |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
Perhaps I hastily presented this reintroduction of [[Opinion Wiki]] in a wrong way indicating that it would have '''something to do with forming the opinion on what to publish and what not.''' This is absolutelly not the case, but it is meant to provide a place dedicated to voicing our opinions on things. In all [[large public wiki]]s this is done on the [[User_talk:Juxo/Blog/June2004|talk page]] of the article and all [[CPOV]] stuff is quietly moved to that talk page. In the scheme of organising things that has clarified in my head we won't be importing talk-pages though it is constructive to place a link to the talk-page of research wiki if there has been heated discussion on what is [[NPOV]] in each case. | Perhaps I hastily presented this reintroduction of [[Opinion Wiki]] in a wrong way indicating that it would have '''something to do with forming the opinion on what to publish and what not.''' This is absolutelly not the case, but it is meant to provide a place dedicated to voicing our opinions on things. In all [[large public wiki]]s this is done on the [[User_talk:Juxo/Blog/June2004|talk page]] of the article and all [[CPOV]] stuff is quietly moved to that talk page. In the scheme of organising things that has clarified in my head we won't be importing talk-pages though it is constructive to place a link to the talk-page of research wiki if there has been heated discussion on what is [[NPOV]] in each case. | ||
:So why is this not just called [[talk pages in Research Wiki]] rather than being called "Opinion Wiki"? If you want to use [[MediaWiki]] you have to call it what mediawiki calls it. If you want to have namespaces like critique:Research_wiki_page fine, but same concept. | |||
:by "won't be importing talk pages" you mean the [[Publish Wiki]] won't have them? Fine. what is the disagreement here? Also don't forget [[New Troll point of view]], when new information shows up, and new trolls to propagate it, the existing editors must assume they know less about that subject than they need to, since it's not been a previous area of expertise. Therefore they must back down in favour of more [[troll-friendly]] ways of determining what is so. This won't always be "quiet". | |||
---- | ---- | ||
24.6.2004 | 24.6.2004 | ||