User talk:Juxo: Difference between revisions

User talk:Juxo (edit)

Revision as of 04:26, 31 March 2004

1,538 bytes added , 31 March 2004

no edit summary

Venceremos

5

edits

@@ Line 181: / Line 181: @@
 :Yes. I deleted [[Coca-Cola]] just as I have deleted [[Gus Kouwenhoven]] and [[CIV]] because we are in a planning and development stage and '''yet''' have no [[Research Wiki]] because we haven't figured out the [[Consumerium Process]] which governs it and Publish Wiki. [[User:DanKeshet]] has started a very similar project of it's own called the [[Consumerpedia]], it is also [[wiki]] and [[GFDL]] so we consider it a friendly project even an [[Essential projects|essential project]]. According to our [[Rules]] this [[Development Wiki]] is no place to put info of companies, so I'm copying the article to [[Consumerpedia]] and blanking it here.
+::I don't see anywhere on the [[Rules]] page where it says this "is no place to put info of companies".  It says "Don't write that Company X or Person Y is evil."  I have not written that any company is evil, I wrote that eight Coca-Cola union leaders in Colombia have been killed, which is a fact, and that the Colombian union that covers Coca-Cola is calling for a boycott until Coca-Cola "makes a commitment to respect the human rights of workers".  I did not say Coca-Cola was responsible for the murders.
+:: My primary concern here is that it seems to me people are being misled into thinking that this IS a "place to put info of companies" even though you say that this "is no place to put info on companies".  You say that the Rules page says this, but it does not, it says to not say a company is evil.  Since apparently people keep coming here and making this error, perhaps this is a sign that people think this is a place to put information on companies.  Perhaps you should be more explicit in your warning.  If your Rules page had said what you SAY it said, which it does not - that this "is no place to put info on companies", I would not have posted anything on Coca-Cola.  You seem to have Kafkaesque, unknown rules that people who are unable to derive them from the existing rules are continually breaking, and then you draconianly delete their stuff.  Perhaps you should be more communicative about what people should put up here, and what they should not. [[User:Venceremos|Venceremos]] 07:26, 31 Mar 2004 (EEST)