Talk:Recyclopedia: Difference between revisions
if Recyclopedia was actually anarchist, wouldn't it have NO leadership?
(the violation is not to provide a zip file) |
(if Recyclopedia was actually anarchist, wouldn't it have NO leadership? ) |
||
| Line 30: | Line 30: | ||
It's not a violation to require a password. It's a violation to require a password AND not provide a .ZIP file of all the GFDL material that was contributed at that URL. If any of that is extended, it must be released under GFDL as well, in the same .ZIP. Per-file release would be technically required under the GFDL too, but, let's face it, [[Wikipedia]] doesn't do that either to all IP addresses, so with their bad example Recyclopedia will likely cheat too. | It's not a violation to require a password. It's a violation to require a password AND not provide a .ZIP file of all the GFDL material that was contributed at that URL. If any of that is extended, it must be released under GFDL as well, in the same .ZIP. Per-file release would be technically required under the GFDL too, but, let's face it, [[Wikipedia]] doesn't do that either to all IP addresses, so with their bad example Recyclopedia will likely cheat too. | ||
-------------- | |||
Apparently there is actually no operative web service there now. However, you can't trust anything written about Recyclopedia by [[Wikimedia]] people. If you look at the [http://en.wikipedia.org/w/wiki.phtml?title=Recyclopedia&action=history page history] you see all the usual suspects: | |||
(cur) (last) . . m 23:20, 10 May 2004 . . Angela (delink) | |||
(cur) (last) . . 23:34, 8 May 2004 . . Sam Spade (wikilink) | |||
(cur) (last) . . 23:47, 12 Apr 2004 . . Guaka (Bandwidth Limit Exceeded) | |||
(cur) (last) . . m 21:20, 12 Apr 2004 . . Hephaestos (rm vfd notice) | |||
(cur) (last) . . m 03:10, 3 Apr 2004 . . Guaka (Home page -> * [http://recyclopedia.info recyclopedia.info]) | |||
(cur) (last) . . 02:31, 3 Apr 2004 . . Camembert (remove a sentence which doesn't seem very significant (several things are on the main page, these don't stand out particularly), rewrite a little bit) | |||
(cur) (last) . . 02:02, 3 Apr 2004 . . Btag (delete!) | |||
(cur) (last) . . 01:58, 3 Apr 2004 . . Camembert (make link live again (see talk), format) | |||
(cur) (last) . . 22:58, 2 Apr 2004 . . Jamesday (I suggest that you look at the contributions of 142.177.*.* (known as EntmootsOfTrolls here)at their recent changes - it's a regular contributor there, from Halifax, CA, who chooses not to log in.) | |||
(cur) (last) . . 12:26, 2 Apr 2004 . . Guaka (made link live again (an anonymous users' talk page at Rec. cannot be a reason to make the link dead!)) | |||
(cur) (last) . . 12:05, 2 Apr 2004 . . Jamesday (Made link non-live. Seems little reason to raise the google rank of a site which plans to send trolls our way. See http://recyclopedia.info/wiki/wiki.phtml?title=User_talk:210.87.254.41 .) | |||
(cur) (last) . . 03:46, 2 Apr 2004 . . Atag (looks like Oosterman has visited occasionally, interesting ext. link) | |||
(cur) (last) . . m 03:27, 2 Apr 2004 . . Angela (delink deleted page) | |||
(cur) (last) . . 03:22, 2 Apr 2004 . . Atag (added description of project leadership, removed excessively long statement of goals copied from main page, removed quote about sysops -- unknown attribution) | |||
(cur) (last) . . m 16:04, 29 Mar 2004 . . Vespristiano (Wording change in the first sentence) | |||
(cur) (last) . . 14:57, 29 Mar 2004 . . Hephaestos (if they are indeed affiliated, please revert me) | |||
(cur) (last) . . 14:49, 29 Mar 2004 . . Tim Starling (runs on GetWiki, which is MediaWiki with a different code formatting style and one extra file) | |||
(cur) (last) . . m 14:29, 29 Mar 2004 . . Guaka (+nl) | |||
(cur) (last) . . 14:21, 29 Mar 2004 . . Guaka ([[Disinfopedia]] and [[Consumerium]] are related Mediawiki projects.) | |||
(cur) (last) . . m 14:18, 29 Mar 2004 . . Guaka | |||
(cur) (last) . . 14:14, 29 Mar 2004 . . Guaka (start) | |||
There are so many liars on that list who were involved directly in the attacks that it's fairly obvious why the article exists: to justify [[denial of service attack]] with irrelevant arguments and claims about who was involved. As if that justifies anything. Notice [[User:Atag]] makes a showing again, and "added description of project leadership" which are names he probably invented. Notice also the "removed quote about sysops"! Obvious why they'd remove that. This is evidence that this "Atag" was the one doing the attacks. | |||
If Recyclopedia was actually anarchist, wouldn't it have NO "leadership"? | |||