Editing The Consumerium Exchange

Warning: You are not logged in. Your IP address will be publicly visible if you make any edits. If you log in or create an account, your edits will be attributed to your username, along with other benefits.

The edit can be undone. Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then publish the changes below to finish undoing the edit.

Latest revision Your text
Line 1: Line 1:
''this page is old - most of its issues are covered more generally in [[edits, votes and bets]]; a more general name for this type of scheme is [[answer recommendation]]''
'''The [[Consumerium]] Exchange''' is where people can voice their opinion on which [[disputed article]] or [[campaign]] is closest to the [[truth]] at or over a certain period of time. All such opinions can change, so there is a need for ex-change, to help them evolve.  This must happen quickly so that those who improve their practices are quickly rewarded, and to make it difficult to exploit a good reputation to do hidden harm - which is a common problem.
 
Thus, the purpose of The Consumerium Exchange is to provide a weighting or combined measurement for different opinions, which determines the default opinion shown to the [[consumer]] on each issue.


==Purpose==
This opinion may be of various types, each with their own rules.  For instance, an opinion of the use of a [[resource]] (like [[mahogany tree]]s or [[mangrove tree]]s) or a [[commodity]] (like [[cocoa]]) is different than an opinion of the [[process]] by which a [[product]] or [[service]] comes to the market, e.g. via a [[sweatshop]] or [[prison labour]].  An opinion of a [[company]] or [[country]] will also have its own rules.  Each of these can be stated in a [[Consumerium Contract]] by which users accept obligations to meet the specific terms of the [[social contract]] that they expect all suppliers (to them) to follow.


'''The [[Consumerium]] Exchange''' is where people can voice their opinion on which [[disputed article]] or [[campaign]] is closest to the [[truth]] at or over a certain period of timeAll such opinions can change, so there is a need for ex-change, to help them evolve. This must happen quickly so that those who improve their practices are quickly rewarded, and to make it difficult to exploit a good reputation to do hidden harm - which is a common problem.
Each consumer can override the view of a given [[interest group]] with her/his own [[preferences]] automatically or manuallyOne important preference is the slider to set how much weight direct and indirect votes get. Enabling automatic exclusion of votes based on preferences should also be possible.


Thus, the purpose of The Consumerium Exchange is to provide a weighting or combined measurement for different opinions, which determines the default opinion shown to the [[consumer]] on each issue.
===Distribution of power===
----
==Current Approach on Development==
There is ongoing research work into fulfilling this need as a Wiki under the working title '''[[Opinion Wiki]]'''.
----
==Voting==
Every person gets two votes on each issue:
Every person gets two votes on each issue:
*An [[Indirect Vote]].
*An [[Indirect Vote]].
Line 20: Line 17:


Counter measures against multivoting and vote buying should be meticulously evaluated.  "The [[stock market]]" does this with [[bet]]s - multiple votes and vote buying are easy, but expensive.  A better solution may be out there, but if so, no one seems to have found it yet.
Counter measures against multivoting and vote buying should be meticulously evaluated.  "The [[stock market]]" does this with [[bet]]s - multiple votes and vote buying are easy, but expensive.  A better solution may be out there, but if so, no one seems to have found it yet.
----
==Evaluation of Results==
===Subjective Preferences===
The consumers opinion may be of various types, each with their own rules.  For instance, an opinion of the use of a [[resource]] (like [[mahogany tree]]s or [[mangrove tree]]s) or a [[commodity]] (like [[cocoa]]) is different than an opinion of the [[process]] by which a [[product]] or [[service]] comes to the market, e.g. via a [[sweatshop]] or [[prison labour]].  An opinion of a [[company]] or [[country]] will also have its own rules.  Each of these can be stated in a [[Consumerium Contract]] by which users accept obligations to meet the specific terms of the [[social contract]] that they expect all suppliers (to them) to follow.
Each consumer can override the view of a given [[interest group]] with her/his own [[preferences]] automatically or manually.  One important preference is the slider to set how much weight direct and indirect votes get. Enabling automatic exclusion of votes based on preferences should also be possible.


===Peer review===
===Social network weighting===
Registered members are able to set [[score]]s (with [[comment]]s) on each other extended-FOAF style (Friend Of A Friend/Foe).  For instance one may track only foes, using only negative scores.  This would be by far the best way to proceed - since [[groupthink]] sets in when any group confuses [[social capital]] with instruction.
Registered members are able to set [[score]]s (with [[comment]]s) on each other extended-FOAF style (Friend Of A Friend/Foe).  For instance one may track only foes, using only negative scores.  This would be by far the best way to proceed - since [[groupthink]] sets in when any group confuses [[social capital]] with instruction.


Line 37: Line 28:
:The anwser being no, not campaigns, because it would lead to all sorts of conceptual unclarities, problems with infinite recursion and besides if party A has an view on party B that view is a private matter of Party A, not party C
:The anwser being no, not campaigns, because it would lead to all sorts of conceptual unclarities, problems with infinite recursion and besides if party A has an view on party B that view is a private matter of Party A, not party C
----
----
'''See also:'''
===See also:===
*[[Talk:The Consumerium Exchange|The Talk Page for Discussion on this facility]] which outlines the [[bet]] issue in some great depth.
*[[Talk:The Consumerium Exchange|The Talk Page for Discussion on this facility]] which outlines the [[bet]] issue in some great depth.
Please note that all contributions to Consumerium development wiki are considered to be released under the GNU Free Documentation License 1.3 or later (see Consumerium:Copyrights for details). If you do not want your writing to be edited mercilessly and redistributed at will, then do not submit it here.
You are also promising us that you wrote this yourself, or copied it from a public domain or similar free resource. Do not submit copyrighted work without permission!

To protect the wiki against automated edit spam, we kindly ask you to solve the following CAPTCHA:

Cancel Editing help (opens in new window)