Talk:Opinion Wiki: Difference between revisions

657 bytes added ,  22 December 2003
No edit summary
Line 10: Line 10:


:The only difference between a [[Role:]] and a [[Troll:]] is that you associate an edit with a role before the fact, and with a troll only after it is made.  But this is very important symmetry...
:The only difference between a [[Role:]] and a [[Troll:]] is that you associate an edit with a role before the fact, and with a troll only after it is made.  But this is very important symmetry...
------------
A better name for this is [[edits, votes and bets]].  Since this is all about the relationship between those things.  Juxo position:  betting is bad, voting is not much better, editing can be free-form like Wikipedia and managed by the same informal methods - anything that needs formal process goes to [[Content Wiki]].  [[Trolls]] argue that the Content Wiki will be about consensus so the [[Opinion Wiki]] or the troll proposed [[The Consumerium Exchange]] must be about controversy and create contrasts that let people make the choices that they count on Consumerium to help them make.  So this implies a different kind of formality.
Anonymous user