Opinion Wiki: Difference between revisions
updating, not moving the body YET
(more on the opinion->research question, various ways to express an opinion (some we like, some not, but that tends to depend on our faction)) |
(updating, not moving the body YET) |
||
| (3 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
'' | ''There is little consensus on this issue yet, and some terms are [[factionally defined]]. See [[what to accept as fact]] for more on the basic questions and how they affect [[moral purchasing potential]].'' | ||
[[Trolls]] argue: | |||
:''[[Research Wiki]] is the present name proposed for this function, recognizing that there is some overlap between the R&D wiki function and the long-term need to track trends in terminology, [[faction]] debates and discovery of what is actually considered [[fair]] for the [[Publish Wiki]] in the alternative naming scheme) versus what is "subjective".'' | |||
[[Lawyers]] argue: | |||
:''Please see the [http://www.consumerium.org/wiki/wiki.phtml?title=Opinion_Wiki&diff=0&oldid=1495 The Diff from the last version] or [http://www.consumerium.org/wiki/wiki.phtml?title=Opinion_Wiki&oldid=1495 The original article] for a simpler view before horde(s) of [[trolls]] edited. Or see [[best cases]] for how the opinion wiki should enable the whole project.'' | |||
''[[Consumerium:intermediate page]] has the stable subset of what is below.'' | |||
==Background== | ==Background== | ||
| Line 25: | Line 31: | ||
*[[Consumerium Troll|Troll]] - a group of edits (not users) that Users think all represent some single point of view, maybe one person, or many co-operating, and which anyone can claim to be adding to - a sort of mask or faction. So there might be no actual User: named "Communist" but there might be a "Troll" by that name, and "Communist" opinions could be classified as part of that virtual personality, no matter who wrote them. Like a role account only what belongs in it is defined after the fact. They can't vote, nor bet - but they can have all the opinions they want. The main use of this is to find out if any Users share so much style or opinion with a known troll profile, that they are probably the same person with many votes or accounts. | *[[Consumerium Troll|Troll]] - a group of edits (not users) that Users think all represent some single point of view, maybe one person, or many co-operating, and which anyone can claim to be adding to - a sort of mask or faction. So there might be no actual User: named "Communist" but there might be a "Troll" by that name, and "Communist" opinions could be classified as part of that virtual personality, no matter who wrote them. Like a role account only what belongs in it is defined after the fact. They can't vote, nor bet - but they can have all the opinions they want. The main use of this is to find out if any Users share so much style or opinion with a known troll profile, that they are probably the same person with many votes or accounts. | ||
*[[Consumerium Group|Group]] - must correspond to a real-world registered entity | *[[Consumerium Group|Group]] - must correspond to a real-world registered entity | ||
*[[Consumerium | *[[Consumerium:faction]] - must not conflict with names of real-world entities. Consists of [[Consumerium User|User]]s and [[Consumerium Group|Group]]s and other [[Consumerium:faction]]s - these are for collective and alleged identity | ||
*[[Campaign]] - preferably descriptive names, and preferably recognizable to people doing real world campaigns say in [[NGO]]s. | *[[Campaign]] - preferably descriptive names, and preferably recognizable to people doing real world campaigns say in [[NGO]]s. | ||
| Line 82: | Line 88: | ||
*Please note that the outline contains mainly only those articles and subarticles required to form hierarchies, not much on actual content | *Please note that the outline contains mainly only those articles and subarticles required to form hierarchies, not much on actual content | ||
*Looks like we are going to have [[The Consumerium Exchange|Three classes of votes]]: | *Looks like we are going to have [[The Consumerium Exchange|Three classes of votes]]: | ||
**WikiVote | **[[WikiVote]] | ||
**Direct Vote | **[[Direct Vote]] | ||
**Indirect Vote | **[[Indirect Vote]] | ||
*Duplicate WikiVotes can occour by accident, by purpose and apparently by design eg. [[Group:Association X National Section]] belongs to [[Group:Association X International]] | *Duplicate WikiVotes can occour by accident, by purpose and apparently by design eg. [[Group:Association X National Section]] belongs to [[Group:Association X International]] | ||
**There must be rules on which of the votes gets excluded in this case. | **There must be rules on which of the votes gets excluded in this case. | ||