WikiVote - Revision history

Jukeboksi: moving obsolete stuff from Voting here where it clearly belongs

2012-10-20T10:44:54Z

moving obsolete stuff from Voting here where it clearly belongs

← Older revision		Revision as of 10:44, 20 October 2012
Line 13:		Line 13:

	:::This could be [[factionally defined]] if there is a way for [[faction]]s to register [[distrust]] in each other's methods and reduce their power if a [[Consumerium:audit]] shows them abusing proxies or something. Make them compete to create invincible systems of authentication, or none, as long as they dont claim to speak for [[individual buying criteria]] that they don't speak for.		:::This could be [[factionally defined]] if there is a way for [[faction]]s to register [[distrust]] in each other's methods and reduce their power if a [[Consumerium:audit]] shows them abusing proxies or something. Make them compete to create invincible systems of authentication, or none, as long as they dont claim to speak for [[individual buying criteria]] that they don't speak for.

			----
			= Old obsoleted plans =
			The voting pages are most obviously "noindex, nofollow" ( stops search engines from indexing ) and furthermore copyright of the wiki user i.e. '''not copylefted'''. If someone wants to publish vote sets in another namespace this surely will be allowed or even recommended. ( If NGOs want to publish vote sets it's sort of the revival of the [[indirect vote]]. )

			''See [[edits, votes and bets]] for the debate about how to decide the final
			[[Consumerium buying signal]].''

			Some basic paradigms have been suggested to measure the support of [[campaigns]]:
			*[[Direct Vote]] requires many votes and rewards heavy participation, and,
			*[[Indirect Vote]] requires fewer votes and rewards [[faction]] organization
			*and the oddly-named [[WikiVote]] which seems to overlap with both of them

			==To vote or not to vote?==
			The Policy on Consumerium is that '''voting''' is discouraged for various reasons.

			#) By voting you open up yourself to severe consumption pattern profiling. Please consider [[not using real name]] if you intend to vote.
			#) We don't want any sorts of census effect à la facebook. So please, srsly, don't vote.
			#) Voting is unwiki
			#) ...
			----


			==Planned onwiki vote structure==

			*[[User:Username/My representational vote]] (i.e. proxy or [[Indirect Vote]], this is probably not used at all in the end)
			*[[User:Username/Boycotts]]
			*[[User:Username/Avoids]]
			*[[User:Username/Supports]]
			*[[User:Username/Recommends]]
			*[[User:Username/Hedges]]
			*[[User:Username/Hedges heavily]]

			Use following syntax (vote only once on each "thing")

			*[[Company X]]
			*[[Country X]]
			*[[Product group X]]
			*...

			One can add any number of reasons by prefixing like this (you can intermix commas with "and"s so don't worry about that.

			'''[[Company X]] for [[Reason 1]], [[Reason 2]] and [[Reason 3]]'''

			in the above articles to cast your votes. Vote only once on one thing

			==Voting in the future==
			In the future you can use one line to vote on multiple entities on one line.

			*[[User:Username/Prefers]]
			*[[User:Username/Prefers strongly]]

			All votables that are before the keyword '''over''' gets voted up and every votable after that gets voted down.

			*<font color="Green">Prefers [[X]]</font><font color="Red"> over [[Y]] </font>results in +1 and -1 respectively

			*<font color="Green">Strongly prefers [[X]] and [[Y]] </font><font color="Red"> over Z </font> results in +2, +2 and -2 respectively

			* <font color=green>Strongly prefers [[Product X]] and [[Product Y]]<font color=red> over [[Product Z]]</font> <for [[reason 1]]>

			etc.etc.

			----

			==What's this I keep hearing about a dual voting system?==
			[[Indirect Vote]]s probably won't be implemented due to lack of interest

142.177.92.200 at 19:53, 3 March 2004

2004-03-03T19:53:58Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 19:53, 3 March 2004
Line 11:		Line 11:
	* how is [[w:user authentication]] performed? By just accounts and passwords, or by IP number, or what?		* how is [[w:user authentication]] performed? By just accounts and passwords, or by IP number, or what?
	::The existence of multiple levels of authentication is the basic approach, but the details are yet quite open.		::The existence of multiple levels of authentication is the basic approach, but the details are yet quite open.

			:::This could be [[factionally defined]] if there is a way for [[faction]]s to register [[distrust]] in each other's methods and reduce their power if a [[Consumerium:audit]] shows them abusing proxies or something. Make them compete to create invincible systems of authentication, or none, as long as they dont claim to speak for [[individual buying criteria]] that they don't speak for.

142.177.92.200: how issues are elaborated?

2004-03-03T19:52:18Z

how issues are elaborated?

← Older revision		Revision as of 19:52, 3 March 2004
Line 5:		Line 5:

	* which [[w:voting system]] should you use? for what purposes?		* which [[w:voting system]] should you use? for what purposes?
	::The question is already ~~anwsered~~ elsewhere, though disagreeing views are welcome. The current proposition is a one-to-one vote: You have one WikiVote per issue. A more interesting question is how and by who is defined what is an "issue". Obivious issues are a [[company]], a [[brand]], a [[product]] and a [[product group]] so we should start with these basics and then expand.		::The question is already answered elsewhere, though disagreeing views are welcome. The current proposition is a one-to-one vote: You have one WikiVote per issue. A more interesting question is how and by who is defined what is an "issue". Obivious issues are a [[company]], a [[brand]], a [[product]] and a [[product group]] so we should start with these basics and then expand.

			**See [[m:TIPAESA]] for an outline of a typical issue position argument structure. Presumably something can't be a [[Consumerium:issue]] until it has had some time to be elaborated, if this is to be a [[w:deliberative democracy]].

	* how is [[w:user authentication]] performed? By just accounts and passwords, or by IP number, or what?		* how is [[w:user authentication]] performed? By just accounts and passwords, or by IP number, or what?
	::The existence of multiple levels of authentication is the basic approach, but the details are yet quite open.		::The existence of multiple levels of authentication is the basic approach, but the details are yet quite open.

142.154.98.75: argumentated is not a word

2003-11-30T23:50:45Z

argumentated is not a word

← Older revision		Revision as of 23:50, 30 November 2003
Line 2:		Line 2:

	* can you change a vote after you make it?		* can you change a vote after you make it?
	::Sure. You can remove your vote simply by removing it from your [[User:UserName/MyVotes]] page perhaps to switch to support an another more credible, better ~~argumentated~~ campaign.		::Sure. You can remove your vote simply by removing it from your [[User:UserName/MyVotes]] page perhaps to switch to support an another more credible, better-argued campaign.

	* which [[w:voting system]] should you use? for what purposes?		* which [[w:voting system]] should you use? for what purposes?

Jukeboksi: preliminary anwsers to questions raised about WikiVotes

2003-10-14T11:31:50Z

preliminary anwsers to questions raised about WikiVotes

← Older revision		Revision as of 11:31, 14 October 2003
Line 2:		Line 2:

	* can you change a vote after you make it?		* can you change a vote after you make it?
			::Sure. You can remove your vote simply by removing it from your [[User:UserName/MyVotes]] page perhaps to switch to support an another more credible, better argumentated campaign.

	* which [[w:voting system]] should you use? for what purposes?		* which [[w:voting system]] should you use? for what purposes?
			::The question is already anwsered elsewhere, though disagreeing views are welcome. The current proposition is a one-to-one vote: You have one WikiVote per issue. A more interesting question is how and by who is defined what is an "issue". Obivious issues are a [[company]], a [[brand]], a [[product]] and a [[product group]] so we should start with these basics and then expand.

	* how is [[w:user authentication]] performed? By just accounts and passwords, or by IP number, or what?		* how is [[w:user authentication]] performed? By just accounts and passwords, or by IP number, or what?
			::The existence of multiple levels of authentication is the basic approach, but the details are yet quite open.

142.177.103.185 at 00:28, 14 October 2003

2003-10-14T00:28:30Z

New page

A '''WikiVote''' is just a vote taken via a wiki. Some issues:

* can you change a vote after you make it?

* which [[w:voting system]] should you use? for what purposes?

* how is [[w:user authentication]] performed? By just accounts and passwords, or by IP number, or what?